Maingear MG-1 (i5-14600K / RTX 4070 Ti / 32GB RAM / 2TB SSD) vs NZXT Player Three Prime (i9-13900KF / RTX 4090 / 128GB RAM / 5TB SSD)
Maingear MG-1 (i5-14600K / RTX 4070 Ti / 32GB RAM / 2TB SSD)
NZXT Player Three Prime (i9-13900KF / RTX 4090 / 128GB RAM / 5TB SSD)
SOURCE ARTICLES
Maingear MG-1 Silver (Shroud Edition) Review: Strong Starter Rig
www.tomshardware.com
Maingear MG-1 Silver (Shroud Edition) Review
Price & Build
- Starts at $1,149 ($1,249 as tested).
- Premium feel, despite being entry-level.
- Excellent cable management.
- Non-proprietary parts, easy upgrades.
Design
- Compact mid-tower: 19 x 16.88 x 8.13 inches.
- Black aluminum chassis, windowed side panel, RGB lighting.
- Shroud Edition: special faceplates, customizable.
Performance
- Intel Core i5-13400F, Nvidia GeForce RTX 4060.
- Decent gaming performance, adjustable settings needed.
- Subpar SSD: 512GB Solidigm P41 Plus.
- 16GB RAM, upgradeable components.
Cooling & Ports
- 4x 120mm fans, Cooler Master Hyper 212 cooler.
- Front: 2x USB 3.2 Gen 1 Type-A, USB 3.2 Gen 2 Type-C, 3.5mm jack.
- Rear: Multiple USB ports, Ethernet, HDMI, audio connectors.
Gaming Benchmarks
- 1080p: Strong performance, 4K: Modest performance.
- Examples: Shadow of the Tomb Raider (104 fps at 1080p), Far Cry 6 (91 fps at 1080p).
Productivity
- Geekbench 6: Single-core 2,330, Multi-core 9,743.
- File transfer: Slow, 489.65 MBps.
- Handbrake: 5:24 for 4K to 1080p transcode.
Software & Warranty
- Minimal pre-installed software.
- Windows 11 bloatware present.
- 1-year warranty, upgradeable to 2 or 3 years.
Bottom Line
- Good starter gaming PC, excellent upgradability.
- Avoid Shroud Edition unless a superfan.
Corsair Vengeance i7500 (i5-14600K / RTX 4070 / 32GB RAM / 1TB SSD) vs MSI MAG Codex 5 13th (i7-13700 / RTX 3070 / 64GB RAM / 1TB SSD): What is the difference?
versus.com
Comparison: Corsair Vengeance i7500 vs MSI MAG Codex 5 13th
Storage:
- SSD: Both have 1TB NVMe SSD (flash storage, faster read/write).
- HDD: Unknown capacity for both.
Components:
-
Corsair Vengeance i7500:
- CPU: i5-14600K
- GPU: RTX 4070
- RAM: 32GB
-
MSI MAG Codex 5 13th:
- CPU: i7-13700
- GPU: RTX 3070
- RAM: 64GB
Form Factor:
- Volume and Dimensions: Unknown for both.
Performance and Features:
- Corsair Vengeance i7500:
- Better GPU (RTX 4070).
- MSI MAG Codex 5 13th:
- More RAM (64GB).
Both use NVMe SSDs and flash storage, ensuring high performance and reliability.
AI COMPARISON
Comparison Table
| Aspect | MaingearMG-1(i5-14600K/RTX4070Ti/32GB/2TBSSD) | NZXTPlayerThreePrime(i9-13900KF/RTX4090/128GB/5TBSSD) |
|---|---|---|
| CPU | Intel Core i5-14600K, 20 threads, Turbo 5.3GHz | Intel Core i9-13900KF, 32 threads, Turbo 5.8GHz |
| GPU | Nvidia RTX 4070 Ti, 12GB GDDR6X, 40.09 TFLOPS | Nvidia RTX 4090, 24GB GDDR6X, 82.58 TFLOPS |
| RAM | 32GB DDR5-6000 MHz | 128GB DDR5-6000 MHz |
| Storage | 2TB NVMe SSD | 5TB NVMe SSD |
| PassMark (Overall) | 39371 | 58812 |
| PassMark G3D (GPU) | 31690 | 39312 |
| Geekbench 6 Multi | 16092 | 20135 |
| Geekbench 6 Single | 2807 | 2974 |
| Cooling | Air cooling, multiple fans | Air cooling, high-TDP capable |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi 6, multiple USB (2x Gen2-A, 4x Gen1-A, 1x Gen1-C), HDMI 2.1, DisplayPort | No Wi-Fi, multiple USB (2x Gen2-A, 4x Gen1-A, 1x Gen1-C, 1x Gen2x2-C), HDMI 2.1, DisplayPort |
| Design | ATX, 205.7mm width, RGB lighting: No | ATX, 227mm width, RGB lighting: No |
| Extra Features | Upgradeable, good cable management | High max memory, extreme GPU performance |
| Review Pros | Strong 1080p gaming, premium feel, good upgradeability | No review text provided, but specs imply high-end 4K/creative workload capability |
| Review Cons | Slow SSD in reviewed lower model, limited dust filters | No review text provided |
Summary
Performance
The NZXT Player Three Prime is a powerhouse with its i9-13900KF and RTX 4090, offering significantly higher GPU TFLOPS, VRAM, and system RAM than the Maingear MG-1. This makes it ideal for 4K gaming, heavy 3D rendering, and professional creative workloads. The Maingear MG-1, with an i5-14600K and RTX 4070 Ti, still delivers excellent gaming performance, particularly at 1080p and 1440p, but it’s not in the same tier for extreme tasks.
Storage & Memory
The NZXT doubles the Maingear’s storage capacity (5TB vs 2TB) and quadruples the RAM (128GB vs 32GB), making it better suited for large datasets, multitasking, and future-proofing. Both use DDR5-6000 RAM and NVMe SSDs, but the Maingear review notes that in a lower-tier configuration, the SSD speed was slower—this specific config may avoid that.
Connectivity & Networking
The Maingear includes Wi-Fi 6, making it more flexible for wireless setups, while the NZXT lacks built-in Wi-Fi, leaning towards wired connections for maximum stability. Both offer modern USB, HDMI 2.1, and DisplayPort options.
Design & Cooling
Both are ATX towers without RGB lighting. The Maingear has a narrower chassis, potentially fitting in slightly tighter spaces. Cooling is air-based in both, but NZXT’s higher TDP CPU suggests stronger cooling requirements.
Upgradeability
The Maingear review praises its easy access and non-proprietary components, which should make upgrading straightforward. NZXT’s larger RAM capacity and higher component ceilings mean it’s already maxed for many users but remains expandable within its platform limits.
Recommendations
- For Competitive Gamers (1080p/1440p) → Maingear MG-1: Offers great frame rates, efficient cooling, and strong value for performance without overpaying for 4K-focused hardware.
- For 4K Gamers & Creative Professionals → NZXT Player Three Prime: Handles ultra-high-resolution gaming, video editing, 3D rendering, and AI workloads with ease.
- For Wireless Setup Users → Maingear MG-1: Built-in Wi-Fi makes it more convenient without extra adapters.
- For Multi-Tasking Power Users & Data-Heavy Workflows → NZXT Player Three Prime: Massive RAM and storage capacity for professional-grade multitasking and huge project files.
Do you want me to also include a value-for-money assessment based on performance vs. likely price for these two? That would make the recommendation even sharper.
ASK AI
BestVs.ai
Hello, I'm your AI shopping assistant. How can I help you?
AI can make mistakes. Consider checking important information.
