Corsair One i500 (i9-14900K / RTX 4090 / 64GB RAM / 2TB SSD) vs Maingear MG-1 (i9-14900KS / RTX 4070 Ti / 32GB RAM / 4TB SSD)
Corsair One i500 (i9-14900K / RTX 4090 / 64GB RAM / 2TB SSD)
Maingear MG-1 (i9-14900KS / RTX 4070 Ti / 32GB RAM / 4TB SSD)
SOURCE ARTICLES
Corsair One i500 (i9-14900K / RTX 4090 / 64GB RAM / 2TB SSD) review
versus.com
Corsair One i500 Review
Specs:
- CPU: i9-14900K
- GPU: RTX 4090
- RAM: 64GB
- Storage: 2TB NVMe SSD
Storage Details:
- SSD: Flash memory, better performance than HDD, no mechanical components, silent, shock-resistant
- NVMe: PCIe interface, higher bandwidth, faster read/write speeds
Physical Dimensions:
- Form Factor: Compact
- Volume: Space enclosed by chassis
- Thickness: Depth of product
- Height: Vertical dimension
- Width: Horizontal dimension
Corsair One i500 (2024) Review w/ 14900K + 4090 - KitGuru
www.kitguru.net
Corsair One i500 (2024) Review
Pros:
- Aesthetic: Beautiful with wooden front panel.
- Performance: Top-tier gaming with RTX 4090.
- CPU Power: Increased to 200W (from 165W).
- Memory: 64GB fast, low latency.
- Controls: Nifty front panel RGB controls.
- Access: Easy internal access.
- I/O: Plentiful.
- Software: Not reliant on iCUE.
Cons:
- Price: Very expensive (£4699.99).
- Size: Significantly bigger (21.7L).
- Storage: Only 2TB at this price.
- CPU Performance: Limited by 200W PL1.
- Noise: Gets loud under load.
Corsair One i500 Review
www.pcmag.com
Corsair One i500 Review Summary
Price & Specs: Starts at $3,599.99; tested at $4,699.99. Features 14th Gen Intel Core i9 CPU, Nvidia GeForce RTX 4090 GPU, 64GB RAM, 2TB SSD.
Design: Compact tower with unique real wood front panel. Touch-enabled lighting strip. User-upgradable (except GPU).
Performance: Outperforms larger, pricier systems. Excels in gaming and content creation benchmarks.
Cooling: Liquid-cooled CPU and GPU for efficient, quiet operation.
Pros:
- Handsome, compact design
- Top performance
- Efficient liquid cooling
- Good value for premium components
- User-upgradable (with GPU caution)
Cons:
- GPU upgrades require Corsair service
Verdict: Editors’ Choice for compact high-end gaming desktops.
Corsair One i500 review: can a gaming PC evolve gamer culture by embracing old, forgotten ways?
Corsair One i500 Review Summary
Design:
- Unique wood panel, fabric sides, aluminum case.
- Small form factor, reminiscent of Atari 2600.
- Limited RGB, no Corsair iCue software.
- Fabric panels may grime over time.
Specs:
- Starts at $3,599.99 / £3,499.99.
- Intel Core i9-14900K, 2TB NVMe storage.
- RTX 4080 Super (base), RTX 4090 (max).
- 32GB DDR5 RAM (base), 64GB DDR5 RAM (max).
Performance:
- Excellent 4K gaming, up to 60FPS.
- RTX 4090 handles Cyberpunk 2077 at max settings.
- Great for gaming, competent for creative tasks.
Limitations:
- Not easily upgradable.
- Small form factor restricts GPU upgrades.
Conclusion:
- Stylish, high-performance, expensive.
- Suitable for non-tinkerers wanting premium aesthetics and performance.
Corsair One i500 review: A bigger small PC
Corsair One i500 Review: Key Points
- Price: $3,599.99
- Design: Larger chassis, wood front panel, RGB lighting, fabric side filters.
- Specs: Intel Core i9-14900K, Zotac RTX 4080 Super, 32GB DDR5 RAM, 2TB SSD, Wi-Fi 6E, Bluetooth 5.3.
- Cooling: 3x 120mm intake fans, 2x 120mm top fans, liquid-cooled CPU & GPU.
- Ports: Front: 2x USB 3.2 Gen 1 Type-A, USB 3.2 Gen 1 Type-C, 3.5mm audio jack. Rear: 8 USB ports, Ethernet, audio ports, DisplayPort, HDMI.
- Performance: Excellent gaming and productivity, slightly behind RTX 4090 systems in 4K.
- Upgradeability: Easier than previous models, CPU, memory, storage upgradable without voiding warranty. GPU upgrade requires customer support.
- Software: Corsair One Dashboard for RGB and monitoring, minimal bloatware.
- Dimensions: 15.3 x 11.8 x 7.6 inches.
Corsair One i500 review: more than a pretty face
Corsair One i500 Review
MSRP: $4,700
Pros: Beautiful design, strong performance, minimal bloatware, back I/O light, upgradeable
Cons: Expensive, CPU runs hot
Specs:
- CPU: Intel Core i9-14900K
- GPU: Nvidia RTX 4090
- Cooling: Liquid for GPU/CPU
- RAM: 64GB DDR5-6000
- Storage: 2TB NVMe SSD
- Power Supply: 1000W SFX 80 Plus Gold
- Networking: 2.5G Ethernet, Wi-Fi 6E, Bluetooth 5.3
- USB Ports: Multiple USB 2.0, 3.2 Gen 2 Type-C, 3.1 Gen 2 Type-A
Performance: Slightly lower CPU performance due to thermal limits, excellent GPU performance, minimal noise.
Build Quality: High-quality components, attractive wooden finish, tight design, standard-sized components for upgrades.
Thermals: Efficient GPU cooling, high CPU temperatures under load, acceptable during gaming.
Software: Proper configuration, minimal bloatware, MSI motherboard BIOS.
Conclusion: Premium, powerful, and compact, but expensive and with limited configuration options.
Maingear MG-1 (i9-14900KS / RTX 4070 Ti / 32GB RAM / 4TB SSD) review
Maingear MG-1 Review
Key Specs:
- Processor: i9-14900KS
- GPU: RTX 4070 Ti
- RAM: 32GB
- Storage: 4TB NVMe SSD
Highlights:
- Storage Type: NVMe SSD, faster than SATA SSDs.
- Advantages: Flash memory, no mechanical components, silent operation, shock resistance.
- Performance: Higher read/write speeds due to PCIe interface.
Dimensions:
- Volume: Space occupied by the chassis.
- Thickness (Depth): Depth of the product.
- Height: Vertical dimension.
- Width: Horizontal dimension.
+ 4
AI COMPARISON
Comparison Table
| Feature | Corsair One i500 | Maingear MG-1 |
|---|---|---|
| CPU | Intel i9-14900K | Intel i9-14900KS |
| GPU | NVIDIA RTX 4090 (82.58 TFLOPS) | NVIDIA RTX 4070 Ti (40.09 TFLOPS) |
| RAM | 64GB DDR5 | 32GB DDR5 |
| Storage | 2TB NVMe SSD | 4TB NVMe SSD |
| Form Factor | Micro ATX | ATX |
| Cooling System | Custom 120mm AIO cooler | Not specified |
| Size (cm³) | 22047.3 | 42557.4 |
| Width | 187 mm | 205.7 mm |
| Height | 393 mm | 482.6 mm |
| Thickness | 300 mm | 428.7 mm |
| Wi-Fi | Wi-Fi 6E, 6, 5, 4 | Wi-Fi 6, 5, 4 |
| Bluetooth | 5.3 | 5.3 |
| Ports | Multiple USB including Type-C, DisplayPort, HDMI | Multiple USB including Type-C, DisplayPort, HDMI |
| Price Range | $3600 - $4700 | Not specified |
| Performance Notes | High performance for 4K gaming and multitasking | High storage capacity, performance details not fully specified |
| Cooling/Thermal Notes | Liquid cooling, quiet under strain | Not specified |
| Design | Compact with wooden front panel | Larger with not detailed design features |
| Upgradeability | Possible but challenging | Not specified |
Summary
- Performance: The Corsair One i500 features a more powerful setup with the Intel i9-14900K and NVIDIA RTX 4090, making it ideal for intensive gaming and high-performance tasks. It also has a significant advantage in RAM capacity. The Maingear MG-1, while sporting a slightly advanced CPU (i9-14900KS), pairs with a less powerful RTX 4070 Ti and offers less RAM, suggesting it might not reach the same performance peaks but compensates with double the SSD storage capacity.
- Design and Size: The Corsair One i500 is noted for its more compact and attractive design, making it suitable for users with limited space and a preference for aesthetic design. In contrast, the Maingear MG-1 is considerably larger, which may be less appealing for users with space constraints.
- Cooling and Noise: The Corsair has a robust cooling system and operates quietly even under load, thanks to its custom 120mm AIO cooler and efficient thermal design. The Maingear MG-1’s cooling details aren't specified, which might be a concern for potential overheating or noise.
- Upgradeability and Connectivity: Both systems offer a range of modern connectivity options including USB-C and Wi-Fi capabilities. Corsair's design, however, is noted to be challenging for upgrades due to its compact nature.
Recommendations
- For High-End Gamers and Power Users: The Corsair One i500 is recommended due to its superior graphics performance, large RAM, and efficient cooling—ideal for 4K gaming and heavy multitasking.
- For Users Needing Large Storage: The Maingear MG-1 with its 4TB SSD may be suitable for users who prioritize storage over raw processing power, such as for extensive media collections or large project files.
- For Aesthetic-Conscious Users: The Corsair One i500 offers a unique, compact design with a wooden front panel that can blend well with home decor while still providing top-tier performance.
ASK AI
BestVs.ai
Hello, I'm your AI shopping assistant. How can I help you?
AI can make mistakes. Consider checking important information.
